jester! wrote: but what is it that is different about VQ4 that Q4Max cannot provide for you?
Its playable out of the box.
We all have to acknowledge that the numbers playing q4 online regularly are well below expectations. A lot of this has to do with its apparent unfriendliness to new players (a problem exasperbated by the autodl bug).
I feel its certainly important for the time being, that public servers run vQ4 to enable newcomers to the series (or maybe even genre) to connect and play games with realtive ease (we won't go into custom maps here). In time some of these players may progress onto mods, others may choose to stay with vq4 - its all about choice and preference.
The FPS arguement is a strong one, and certainly makes the difference between q4 being playable or not to some people. But its not a simple as all switching to a mod - I fear if we did we'd loose potential players overnight